Click to Call
Watchdog Insurance Group

423 Woodlawn Ave
O'Fallon, MO 63366

Get Directions

Our Associate Agents

Request More Information

Our Associate Agents

Chris Yettke

Chris Yettke Sr.

Licensed in MO/KS/IL/WI/IN

Chris Yettke Sr.  Founded Watchdog Insurance Group in 2017 after 5 years of being a captive agency owner. Over the last 10 years in the indurance industry, Chris has also been actively involved in the community as a prior Lion's Club President and a Chamber of Commerce Ambassador. 

Having been successful in roofing/siding sales prior to insurance and furniture before that. Chris learned from his Grandfather, "It's never about the sale but the service after. You treat a client right. You shoot them straight and never lie. You'll have a client for life." That is when we started consulting vs selling. 

Chris married Stephanie in 2013, they have 2 children Chris Jr. and Shyanna. They live in O'Fallon, MO and love traveling to the beach and going omn hikes! When not helping clients save money Chris is either with his family, weight lifting or fishing. 

Having grown up in Missouri, Chris is a Cardinals fan for life! GO REDBIRDS!!! Football has been an interesting rollar coaster.... Chiefs were always his favorite growing up, then the Lambs( aka Rams) briefly stole his heart! Glad to see them go! Chiefs Nation!!!

Chris's motto has always been Yettke's got your back! But now we all feel Watchdog's got your back! 



Brennen Thoma

Brennen Thoma

Licensed in WI/MO

Brennen started his Insurance career in April of 2018 as an Independent insurance agent primarily offering auto and home insurance. As he grew in his career he has gained knowledge and relationships on the commercial side. He has expanded his commercial insurance offerings for many business’s including specializing in the Trucking Insurance. Brennen is licensed in Wisconsin, Illinois, Missouri, Kansas, Indiana, and Texas. He prides himself on his 5 star customer service, and always put his clients best interests first.

Brennen married his wife Emily on Oct 8th 2016. He enjoys anything cooking related especially meat smoking and BBQing. He has created a FB group called “Wisconsin Meat Smoking Hobbyist” that is growing daily and has over 17,000 members currently from the state of Wisconsin. He also is the founder and president of a state wide (Wisconsin) meat smoking club called Meat Smoking Club of Wisconsin.

Brennen’s number one priority is delivering a positive and personal experience when it comes to shopping your insurance and he will do anything he can to make sure your experience is nothing short of a 5 star experience. 


Caleb Pagel

Caleb Pagel

Licensed in MO/IL/WI/IN

Caleb's insurance experience started in claims in 2014, he then transitioned to the sales side as an independent insurance agent in 2017. Caleb strives for the customer experience to be nothing short of 5 stars. His expertise is in auto and home insurance, but has a lot of knowledge and experience working in the commercial insurance arena as he has established a good working relationship with many businesses in the St. Louis area.

Caleb is married to his wife Emily since 2018 and has a daughter that was born February 2020. He enjoys all kinds of sports, specifically enjoys playing golf and watching football and hockey, and he is a big fan of all of the St. Louis sports team.

“I have lived in the St. Louis area since 2016, and I love the St. Louis area and what it has to offer to it’s residents. From sporting events, to BBQ and other fantastic local restaurants, to activities like going to the one of the best zoos in the country, St. Louis has something to offer to everyone. My main goal is to establish a great relationship with each customer and provide the residents of St. Louis and the surrounding areas a great experience when it comes to shopping their insurance. Making sure everyone is properly protected while giving them the best rate is part of that experience and that’s what sets us apart from other agencies.”


Kirk Faubel

Kirk Faubel

Licensed in MO/KS/IL/WI

I conduct my insurance business in an effort to build a stronger community.  As the 2019 Chamber Volunteer of the year, it is important to me to be able to give back to my community.  I have spent over 25 years running businesses that focused on providing great customer experiences.  I take an educational approach to helping clients understand how specific coverage's can help protect them.  This all starts with gaining a good understanding of what I am protecting and what the clients expectations are if something bad happens.  My service doesn't end when the policy is written as I encourage my clients to reach out when they have needs or questions.  I have a wealth of resources available to help my clients with just about any need whether it is a roof repair, a remodeler, or just a great place to have a nice dinner.

I was born and raised in Wisconsin, but have called the St Louis area home for 17 years.  I married my beautiful wife, Becky in 2014 and we have 4 kids in our blended home.  Aaron, Taylor, Bryson and Abby.  In my free time, I love working on projects on our 92 year old Kirkwood home, traveling, hiking, and taking in sporting events. While the Packers will forever be in my Blood, I am a huge Cardinals and Blues fan, and looking forward  to St Louis SC in a couple of years.  I am also a bit of a bourbon hobbyist so you will possibly see me around town at some St Louis Bourbon Society events or one of many amazing restaurants.


Ryan Sublett

Ryan Sublett

Licensed in MO/KS

Born in Texas raised in Kansas City, I have lived in the metro area for the last 20 years. Helping people and being a part of the community have always been important to me, and being in this industry has given me the opportunity to do both. It is my priority to help my clients save money, but also have the right protection for their families and most valuable assets. In my spare time I enjoy being with family, and supporting all of Kansas City sports teams, and of course my beloved Texas Longhorns!


Benjamin Shafer

Benjamin Shafer

Licensed in




Right 1st image

Locally owned and operated

Right 2nd image

Policies that meet & exceed expectations

Right 3rd image

Get an Annual Policy review

Servicing States

  • Missouri
  • Illinois
  • Kansas
  • Wisconsin
  • Indiana